Secretive-
The Nacerima people have many hidden traditions that they don’t even share with
their families. The only time their certain rituals are even discussed are
still in secret but are talked about with the children so they can learn how to
do their own rituals privately. There is so much secretiveness even about the
human body; women and men do not even see each other’s body parts. Sex has to
be scheduled and is kept to a minimum and when women are pregnant that have to
hide the fact that they are carrying a child. Most of their rituals are magic
based and they even keep a secret box or chest with little charms for their
rituals. They have a temple which they send their sick to but know body really knows
what the medicine men do in the temple to heal the sick that enter it. They
only know that many people don’t survive the poking and prodding.
Uneducated- The
Nacerima have been practicing the same rituals for hundreds of years and they haven’t
advanced from when they first started as a civilization. They still have the
same holy-mouth-men that do horrible, painful operations to their mouths after
all of these years. They let the holy mouth men make your teeth rot. They also practice
magic with voodoo dolls. Nothing seem to ever be discussed therefore nothing
can really ever advance in society. They seem to stand stagnate in their
culture because of their everyday rituals which take up most of their day, they
also have population control because many don’t want to procreate because they
believe the human body is so disgusting.
Untrustworthy- It
seems that no one in the Nacerima culture trust one another. The text states
that some of the children have to visit the “listener” to rid themselves of
demons that they might have collected when their mothers started to teach them
about how they will conduct their own rituals. The people of this culture even
think that certain mothers bewitch their own children when they are teaching
them about the secret body ritual. There seems to be know trust between the men
and women of this culture and there are seems to be a lot of rejection. Mothers
aren’t even allowed to show they are pregnant and most of them don’t breast
feed their children as well because it is looked down upon.
Persistent- It
seems to me that the Nacerima people are very persistent. They always go back to
the holy mouth men a few times a year even after the grueling pain and rotting
of the teeth. They also stick to their daily schedule of the worshiping of
their shire in the privacy of their own home. These people have a very strict
lifestyle and keep carrying on the traditions with their children. They have a
few very important members of their society that they always look upon: the
first is the holy mouth man, the listener and the medicine man. The people rely
on these few members to help them through their everyday life. They also send
their sick to a temple but only if they can afford it to be tortured, poked and
prodded because they think it will heal their sick. Many people that enter the
temple do die, most call it the temple of death, but many people still want to
go into the temple.
Fascinating-
The people of Nacerima are very fascinating to me. They do the same rituals
everyday and have continued to do them for many years. I find it very unusual
that they husband and wives are even so secretive with each other and that
mothers seem like they abandon their own children once they are born. Family doesn’t seem to be a very important
part of their culture. I also can’t believe they put themselves through so many
painful rituals just for the acceptance, I guess you wouldn’t know any different
if you were brought up in such a culture. They also focus a lot on magic and
hope for healing and rejuvenation for their medicine men. It’s amazing that
they are so not accepting of the human body and try extremely hard to hide it
rather than learn from it and accept it. Fascinating is the perfect word to descried
this culture because they are so different form my own.
Part B
As
an American, how do you feel about your choice of descriptive words in Part
A?
I think that almost all of my words pretty much describe
American people as well. The only word that I would say doesn’t fit the all
American as a whole would be uneducated. I think there are many educated
Americans but there are defiantly more uneducated people in America today. After I read the article and wrote my first
blog I researched about the Nacerima people and saw that it was actually a joke
about the American people today.
Do
any of your choices exhibit ethnocentrism on your part? In other words, do any of your descriptive
words reveal a judgment of the Nacerima rooted in your own cultural bias? Are any of your words free of bias?
I think I did judge the culture strictly off of their
rituals and beliefs. Everyone is bias in one way or another, every time anyone
has an opinion it is bias. I think that saying that the Nacerima people are
uneducated, untrustworthy and persistent is judgmental. I also think a lot of
the words I chose have to do with the way I was raised and with the American
people today. The only word that I think that is free of being bias is
fascinating because when I described this word I stated facts and not just
opinions.
For
any of the words that are biased, can you provide alternate words that are free
of bias but communicate the same explanatory information and intent of your
original word?
I think that the word secretive is a little bias and I
think it could be changed to reserved instead because that is less judgmental. The Nacerima are people who don’t like to share
much with others and keep things to themselves. They are more reserved about
their body parts and don’t like to share them with others. I also think that I could
change the word uneducated to misunderstand. Not every culture has as many opportunities
to be educated and learn about the world like we can. Just because people are
different doesn’t mean there way is wrong.
From
this experience, reflect on the importance of avoiding ethnocentric judgments
when describing other cultures. Why is
it important to describe another culture in a manner as free from personal
cultural bias as possible? Do you think
it is possible to completely avoid personal cultural bias as a Cultural
Anthropologist?
I think it is important to be able to step outside of
your own personal feelings and experiences in order to really understand and
learn from other cultures. There are so many different cultures from our own
and in order to even try and understand why different cultures conduct
different rituals we have to be open. I don’t
think it is totally possible to not include some cultural bias because everyone
has judgments about everything even if they don’t know they are even being judgmental,
but it is important to try.
Very good post. I liked how you thought through your alternatives to the words you originally chose.
ReplyDeleteBy the way, just because a word expresses bias, doesn't mean it doesn't "fit"or isn't accurate, as long as you understand that the accuracy itself is culturally biased. From your perspective, reading the article, the culture of the Nacirema can be described as uneducated. You can back that up from the article. But it still carries bias. Does that make sense?
I'm glad I'm not the only one who found the Nacerima people to be fascinating. But I did find it interesting to see that it was my own culture being described, which made me realize that I am, in fact, interested in the culture I live in (not to mention cultures I don't live in).
ReplyDeleteYou made a good point about needing to step outside of your personal experiences and feelings to really understand others. I don't feel like I did that well enough in my own blog in part A. It made me aware that I need to do that more.
"Nacirema culture is characterized by a highly developed market economy which has evolved in a rich natural habitat...much of the people's time is devoted to economic pursuits"
ReplyDeleteHow do you find that a culture thriving from a self-implimented economy is uneducated?
Tavia... Good question!
ReplyDelete